Wong, Wai Yip2019-09-252019-09-252017-10-222013-01http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12424/166780Hick's pluralist assumption has remained the most knowable model of religious pluralism in the last few decades. Many have, from the perspectives of various major world religions, questioned his notion that the teachings of all religions are derived from the same Absolute Truth and that the salvific-end is one, yet little attention has been paid to the traditions that he graded as unauthentic and non-valuable according to his soteriological and ethical criteriology. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the exclusiveness of Hick‟s model by describing a tradition called “Chinese Folk Religion” that does not fit into his definition of “authentic religion.” Hick‟s understanding of the concept of salvation/liberation and his interpretations of the teachings of the major world religions are over-generalized and simplified, and his particular criteriology does not treat all traditions fairly or pluralistically. As a response, this paper argues that it is necessary to reconstruct Hick‟s criteriology if we wish to fulfil the original purpose of promoting the pluralist hypothesis. Abstract in Chinese: 过去数十年间,希克的多元主义假设一直是最广为人知的多元理论。很多学者曾从世界主流宗教的视角,质疑他有关所有宗教信仰皆源自同一终极真理或救赎的目的地只有一个的说法。但是,按照希克的理论,有一些传统将因为无法达到他设定的救赎及伦理标准,而被评为不可信及无价值的信仰传统。人们很少从这个方面提出质疑。因此,本文将以被忽视的中国民间宗教为例,展示希克理论的排他性。藉着比较中国民间宗教与其多元主义的不兼容之处,本研究指出他对于救赎概念的理解和对世界宗教信仰的诠释皆过于笼统化和简单化,以及他评价宗教信仰的标准对中国宗教及传统哲学有欠公平。作为回应,本文提出只有重新构建审核世界宗教的标准,才能有效达致其宣扬多元主义的本来目的.engInstitute of Sino-Christian Studies (ISCS) ; Institute of Comparative Scripture and Inter-religious Dialogue, Minzu University of ChinaJohn HickpluralismChinese folk religionIntercultural and contextual theologiesAsian theologiesIncompatibility between Chinese Folk Religion and John Hick’s CriteriologyArticle